wich explains why the graph is not a function
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2f12b/2f12b8e96c6962ea3e3ddb685d8b64432ef15a7d" alt="wich explains why the graph is not a function class="
The correct answer is D.
For a series of values to be a function, you cannot have two y-values for the same x-value, as this makes the function fail the vertical line test, and thus not meet the criteria for being considered a function.